What are the odds that the star of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 would appear on Jimmy Fallon’s Tonight Show and then be asked to sing the iconic theme song of the superhero’s 1960s Saturday morning cartoon show?

If you’re Andrew Garfield, the odds are as amazing as Spider-Man himself. The actor eventually succumbed to Jimmy’s entreaties and performed his own folk-infused version of the tune. Even though Andrew claims it’s the first time he’s ever sung in public, his rendition is guaranteed to get your toes tapping and your Spidey senses tingling. Take a look: