Billy Joel continued his residency at Madison Square Garden on Saturday night, and fans who attended the show were in for a double surprise when the Piano Man introduced a pair of special guests to join him onstage: Paul Simon and Miley Cyrus.

To the delight of fans, Joel was joined by Simon and Cyrus in a rousing rendition of his 1980 hit “You May Be Right” (which you can watch above).

RELATED: Miley Cyrus Reunites With Best Friend Lesley, Performs With Dad Billy Ray At Nashville Album Party

In addition, the “Wrecking Ball” singer also lent her vocals to a duet with Joel, taking on his iconic Big Apple anthem “New York State of Mind” (below).

Following her surprise performance, Cyrus took to Twitter to share a brief snippet of this power trio in action — so let’s keep those fingers crossed that this could be a sneak peek at a hot new supergroup: Simon, Cyrus & Joel!

Click to View Gallery
Miley Cyrus’ Major Milestones