Katie said goodbye to Justin after she had a successful overnight date and exchanged I love yous with Blake Moynes, which led her to tell co-host Kaitlyn Bristowe that her heart “officially belongs” to the wildlife manager.
Justin admitted that he questioned whether or not he should have told Katie that he was falling in love, due to the pain he felt with the breakup.
“When you open up you offer so much,” Katie assured him. “I’m so thankful for our moments… You are such a great man. I know you’ll be a great husband, a great father. It’s not easy. I don’t make this decision lightly. It’s been on my mind all day. And I’m sorry.”
Justin took that in and told Katie, “I think the world of you. Everything that I’ve said to you is 100 percent true. I just hope you know how special you are and what you bring to the table. I hope he knows what he has in you and he doesn’t take you for granted.”
“That means more to me than you’ll probably ever know, truthfully,” she responded.
In a confessional, Katie said that her and Justin’s goodbye was “hard,” largely because Justin “did nothing wrong.” The pair shared a hug, before Justin wished her well. In the limo, though, Justin said that the breakup was “crazy.”
When Katie and Justin met up, she began by explaining how hard the last week had been for her, before explaining why she was ending things with him.
“I know how hard it was to tell me you were falling in love. That’s something I thought about every night since. I was looking forward to today,” she said. “I did have my overnight with Blake and in that I did tell him that I’m falling in love with him. That is something I can only say to one person. You are someone I wanted to explore things with, but given how I now feel about Blake, knowing I am in love with him, it doesn’t make sense to have us go forward on this date. It wouldn’t make sense to have you meet my family. That’s where I’m at.”
“We’ve spent a month together, getting to know each other, talking about our families,” he said. “This morning I’m picturing how great today’s going to be and what our life is gonna look like and that’s it. It’s so hard… You don’t want it to end. It’s hard. It’s hard. It hurts, man. I gave this everything. I feel a lot of emotions.”
On the set of “After the Final Rose”, Justin said that the breakup “hurts just as much now as it did then.”
“For it all to come to a screeching halt, your heart just gets stepped on,” he said. “No one wants to feel like they weren’t good enough… I can’t tell you to follow your heart and make the decision that’s best for you and then be upset when it’s not me, but that doesn’t make it easier.”
When Katie joined Justin on the stage, he questioned whether or not he was there “by default.” Katie said that that wasn’t the case at all, and assured Justin that they had “a huge connection.”
In the end, things ended on a positive note, with Justin thanking Katie for the experience, and telling her that it made him “a better person.”
“That makes me really happy to hear,” Katie replied.
Audiences didn’t see much of Katie and Justin’s relationship until well into the season, a fact that the Bachelorette previously expressed disappointment about to ET.
“It’s really unfortunate because him and I had an early connection, but it wasn’t quite shown until later on,” she said. “… He’s just someone I’ve really enjoyed spending my time with. It was very easy. That’s all you’re looking for when you’re looking for a partner.”
As for how Katie’s journey will come to an end, she previously told ET that she’s “officially made peace with everything that has happened” during her season of the show.
“I am in a place where I am very happy with my life and where I am. That is all I can do to continue to move forward,” she said. “… I’m ready to get out of the house [and] move forward with my life. Just really figure things out and what the future holds for me.”
MORE FROM ET: